Register/ Login   
Submit Mobile RSS Java Script Feed  
Home Blogs Spotlight Videos Movies Cartoon Photos Submit Media Space  Feed Directory 
World |  National |  Entertainment |  General |  Columnist


Published on 17-03-2008 In World
Viewed 1618 times
Is Tibet reaching a decisive phase?
Written by
Mayank Chhaya
Fractures in Lhasa and elsewhere in Tibet run far deeper than not just what China would have the world believe but had probably convinced itself about. It is more than likely that Beijing would stamp out the spiralling protests with urgency mixed with ruthlessness, especially because it is desperate to ensure a smooth conduct of the impending Olympic games. However, what it is unlikely to accomplish is put a firm lid on the searing heat generated by the uprising.

From all available accounts out of Tibet coupled with the tone of the Dalai Lama's reaction, it is becoming clear that a decisive state may have been reached in the six-decade old Sino-Tibetan standoff.
This is particularly surprising because there were no recognizable signs pointing in the direction of such an assertive expression of disaffection. Although the six million Tibetans are singularly ill equipped to take on the mighty Chinese establishment, the timing of the protests is fraught with history and has the potential to fundamentally alter the equation.

The Dalai Lama has said he is "helpless" in the face of such widespread protests and, more importantly, that he would not instruct his followers to relent. On whether he can ask his followers to surrender by midnight on Monday, he told a news conference in McLeod Ganj, "I have no such power."

The Dalai Lama said he had received a call on Saturday from Tibet requesting him not to stop the protesters. He promised he would not. "Now we really need miracle power," he said, "But miracle seems unrealistic." The Dalai Lama has said he has the same sense of foreboding about the current crisis as he had during the March 10, 1959 uprising. He said, according to a Chinese military document between March 1959 and September 1960, 87,000 were people killed.





Since 2006, when the fifth round of talks took place between the representatives of the Tibetan government-in-exile and Beijing, the Dalai Lama has said the attitude inside Tibet has hardened and there has been criticism even of his approach. That was an implicit admission that ordinary Tibetans inside Tibet may no longer be willing to follow his "middle way" approach, which eschews any precipitate action. This could be equally true of the younger generation of Tibetans in exile in India. There are hotheaded Tibetans, whose number is hard to establish, who continue to advocate complete independence as opposed to "meaningful autonomy" being called for by the Dalai Lama.

One of the major reasons behind the current unrest can also be attributed to a growing sense of economic inequity among the local Tibetans compared to the Han Chinese people who have been resettled in the region. The Dalai Lama has referred to the discrimination practiced by the Chinese. Although Beijing has brought about visible development to Lhasa and other areas, it has mainly impacted the Han Chinese population. Riding on top of the sense of having been occupied is this powerful sense of economic inequity which also acting as a trigger for the current violence.

Many Tibetan experts believe that the level of disenfranchisement has grown and in the process compelled them to believe that they have no stake in the current state of affairs. This disaffection could lead to serious problems in the near future. "Wait and see," was the Dalai Lama's response when asked if the discontent among ordinary Tibetans would breach his middle way approach.
 
 2 Comments    Share    Blog      Print
 

Add Your Comment

Join Indiainteracts for free to comment on this story. Have an account already? to comment
2 Comments

What is interesting about the current Tibet situation is the Indian Government’s ‘deafening’ silence on the matter. I am sure the Indian Govt, as do the people of India, feel a sense of solidarity with the hapless plight of the beleagured Tibetians, but for political reasons the Manmohan administration is tight-lipped about taking a bold stance on the matter. While China has the guts and arrogance to fret about the Indian PM’s recent visit to Arunachal Pradesh, the Indian Govt is shy to criticize China’s disgusting use of force against people who it calls its own citizens. If India has any delusions of becoming a legitimate superpower someday, it needs to start standing up for causes it believes in and condemn anti-democratic acts of autocratic goverments throughout the planet. For its part, China, even as it tries to bask in upcoming Olympic glory, can do itself a favor by apologizing to the Tibetian people for its shameless acts of violence against them over the last 50+ years, and sit down with them at the table to negotiate a roadmap for Tibet’s independence.

 
rnarayanan - Comments as on 17-03-2008

Let’s first analyze similarities between the Nazis and the CCP.

1) Nazis were national socialists - CCP is a national socialist.

2) Nazis considered Germans to be the master race - CCP considers Han Chinese to be the master Race.

3) Nazi torch bearers were athletic, strong examples of the “master race” - CCP torch bearers are athletic, strong examples of the “master race”.

4) Nazis glorified the Olympic flame with a mythical, pagan, semi-spiritual status - CCP glorifies the Olympic flame with a mythical, pagan, semi-spiritual status. The men in blue suits are called “The Olympic Holy Flame Protection Unit” and one of them watches the flame while others sleep.

5) Nazis used the games to promote national socialism - CCP uses the games to promote national socialism.

6) Nazi torch bearers loved the Fatherland and gave their life if necessary for the Fuhrer - CCP torch bearers must love the Motherland and give their life if necessary for the CCP.

7) Nazi oath of allegience is to the Fuhrer and to acknowledge The Fuhrer as the savior of Germany - The Chinese oath of allegience is to the CCP and to acknowledge the CCP head as a “Living Buddha”.

8) Nazis had live shooting ranges where they would hunt down civilians and kill them as practice for troops - Chinese have live shooting ranges where they would hunt down civilians and kill them as practice for troops.

9) The Nazi torch bearers actually went back and invaded every country they went through even murdering the gypsies in Bulgaria - The Chinese have already invaded Tibet and other areas and murdered millions of people.

10) The Nazi torch bearers were fanatical national socialists - The Chinese torch bearers were fanatical national socialists.

11) Nazis performed medical experiments and murdered prisoners for medical research and body parts - Chinese murder prisoners to order for body parts and medical research.

The CCP has a clear agenda - “expansionism” at all costs under the guise of peaceful liberation. Once a territory is gone, it’s gone. There will be 1.3 billion brainwashed fools who will come here and defend war crimes of the CCP and brag about Xinhua as free press. If the West remains complacent, South-East, Australia, New Zealand, Pacific would be occupied or rather “liberated” territories in a few decades. Don’t come back and ask us “Why they hated China” or all we had to do is give the Chinese more time to think about the nicety of Western Liberalism.

China’s human rights abuses are “staggering”: the detention of hundreds of thousands of people, including political activists, for “reeducation” programs, and forced labor camps; and the liberal use of the death penalty in China — including for political prisoners — which makes China the site of 8 of every 10 government administered executions carried out in the world!

CCP is full of deceit and has figured out how to play the West. They can’t be trusted at all and they have a bag full of tricks to fool not only Tibetans but the whole world with a state-controlled press. The best solution is a free Tibet. There is no doubt that a sovereign Tibet would be a savior state not only for Tibetans but for all ethnic groups of China who have nowhere to go if they disagree with the CCP. A free Tibet would be such a free democratic heaven and a safe haven.

 
Chrisna - Comments as on 13-04-2008







     

Seval...

Anthony Yaar...

Durai...


Vaaranam Aayiram...

Adada Enna Azhagu...

Abhium Nanum...

Mantra Trailer ...

Kuruvi 150 Days Ce ...

Anthony Yaar Audio ...


Seval Audio Launch ...

A.R.Rahman Launche ...

Gopal Srinivasan T ...
     


About | Content providers | Support | Beta feedback | Report abuse | Contact us | Careers | FAQ