| Published on 03-12-2007 In National |
| Viewed 1781 times |
| The shameful conspiracy of Silence in Gujarat |
|
|
Written by Girish Nikam |
"We have always been treated like a football on a political field",-- Abdul Qahar Pathan "We want to be treated as human beings, equal to other citizens. We also want to enjoy the fruits of development and be a part of the growth story of India." —Mohammed Shahin
These two statements by the two Muslim voters in Gujarat to an IANS correspondent, depict the state of that entire community in Gujarat, as it goes to polls in the next couple of weeks. The sense of alienation is complete among the majority of Muslims in that state, and even the Congress Party does not seem to be doing much to make that feeling go away.
It is amazing that after one of the best pieces of journalistic work done for a long time by the Tehelka, laying bare the anatomy of the 2002 riots in the words of the perpetrators themselves, it has become a non-issue, for even the Congress Party.
More astonishingly the Union Minister for Information and Broadcasting, Priya Ranjan Dasmunshi, not only defended the ban by the Ahmedabad Collector on the TV channels Aaj Tak and Headlines Today which were airing the expose, but also sees a conspiracy in the entire Tehelka expose.
Coming as it did from a Congress Minister, even as a day before its Party President Sonia Gandhi was attacking BJP and Chief Minister Narendra Modi in Gujarat, and even mentioned the expose, belies political reasoning. Now if Dasmunshi really has some evidence that the expose was a conspiracy hatched, as he says by people sitting in "Delhi and Ahmedabad", he should come out with the details.
Any journalist worth his salt would know that such a story cannot be hatched. If anyone cares to read the magazine, which carried the story, the Tehelka correspondent has written in detail how he happened to accidentally come across the story and how he pursued it. By calling it a conspiracy, Dasmunshi has challenged the journalistic integrity of an entire organisation, which has been one of the worst sufferers in the previous BJP-led NDA regime. So does he mean that the Tehelka conspired with Modi and came out with that expose? It is ironical that even BJP calls it a Congress conspiracy.
What is however more disturbing is the silence of the Supreme Court over the matter. Despite it being approached it has remained silent, and the perpetrators of the ghastly crimes who had boasted about their deeds, continue to audaciously move around Gujarat.
And in the election campaign even the opposition leaders are not saying a word about them and their acts. Even Sonia Gandhi after that initial noise, has decided to remain silent on the entire Tehelka expose. The Congress charge sheet against the Modi government only talks about the pitiable condition of the Muslims who had been affected by the riots and their compensation, but no mention of the perpetrators and the Tehelka expose. There is no demand for their arrest and prosecution. A surreal blanket of silence has been spread over the entire expose.
Why? Because the Congress feels that by talking about it they will help Modi to polarize the Hindus and defeat them.
The cynicism has reached such monumental proportions that everyone is behaving as if the expose never happened. No wonder such voices of despair and hopelessness is emanating from the Muslims in Gujarat.
Going by the conspiracy theory of Dasmunshi, it means the NGOs and the concerned citizens who have moved the Supreme Court seeking action against those exposed in the Tehelka story, are also part of the conspiracy. And therefore it would also entail that they are all working to help Modi to return to power, by highlighting the expose and seeking action!
The disturbing question, which crops up because of this dastardly silence being witnessed is--- where do the poor Muslims who have suffered go to now for justice?
The much-distinguished Prof. Juzar Bandukwala therefore has suggested a way out of all this. "Just forgive and forget", he tells the Muslims. The man who himself was a victim of the terror caused by the VHP and RSS cadres, says that at a personal level he has already done it, and wants his community also to do the same. Is Bandukwala saying this, as he sees no hope for justice being done?
If that is the basis for his lonely cry for forgiving and forgetting, it speaks very poorly, not just about the political and justice system, but also of our society in which we live. Can the Gujaratis really live with the enormous amount of blood shed on their hands and without the perpetrators being brought to justice?
Of course there is the other factor of whether such heinous crimes can be forgiven and forgotten? Though at a philosophical level it is possible, at a legal level should it be? Would Gandhiji, who obviously is the inspiration behind Bandukwala's call, be convinced enough to make such a call, and ask the perpetrators to be left Scot-free?
It is also interesting to note that all the reports emanating from Gujarat related to the election campaign, where some even talk of the loosening grip of Narendra Modi and the serious challenge he is facing from within his own party as well as Congress, do not attribute it to his role in the Gujarat riots. It is all related to the rebellion against him in his party because of the way he has marginalized many leaders. And even these BJP leaders who are up in arms against him are not leaving him because of his role in the riots. Obviously because some of them were actively involved in it. It has more to do with the caste equations.
Can we imagine, if the same kind of riots had occurred and the majority of victims were Hindus, such a shroud of silence during an election campaign? Or even if those who had been exposed by the Tehelka were Muslims who were boasting about how they killed Hindus? Would any political party, including the Congress have kept quiet?
This conspiracy of silence over one of the most heinous crimes committed is what marks the Gujarat elections. And it is another shameful chapter in our country's post-independent history, which has to be shared by all political parties and also the judiciary. |
|
|
|
|
| Social Web | |
| |
|
|
| |